1. The Completely Unexpected Departure Of Marsh Hall As I stated yesterday, I think everyone pretty much expected Guy Penrod to part ways with the GVB. (That is in no way a knock on Penrod; his new direction will fit him perfectly.) However, I think that all of us were completely blindsided by Marsh leaving the group. Many have commented on various blogs and websites saying that they thought the press release made it sound like he got canned. That does not seem to be the case, however, after reading this excerpt from this blog post from Emily Sutherland:
“In spite of all the mixed emotions you probably feel, I do want to tell you that I spoke with Marshall today and I’m anxious for you all to hear from him. I’ll work on that, but in the meantime, you need to know that he says performing on-stage has never been his “sweet spot” (though he has done an incredible job of stepping up to the plate for the Vocal Band)! His true love is leading worship… and he is very much looking forward to finding the right situation where he can do that. He is not mad, and he is keeping in touch with Bill as they work together to make this transition smooth and positive. More on that later.”
It appears that a worship leader position is in Hall’s future.
2. The Beginning Of The End? With this recent change in direction, a lot of people seem to think that Bill Gaither has gathered this true “super group” to let the group go out on top, a la The Cathedrals with Ernie, Glen, Scott, George and Roger. Honestly, do you expect him to call Mark, David, and Michael away from their solo careers just to carry out a Farewell Tour? Somehow, I doubt it. I do believe that Bill has a plan for this group to carry on the name after he retires, and possibly bringing in a younger bass when he does do that to keep the five-man thing going.
3. Below Par Vocalists Popular opinion believes that the three alumni Bill has brought back are no longer the great vocalists they were in their prior tenures with the GVB. OK, David Phelps has been counted out of that statement in every such comment I’ve seen.
However, I beg to differ about the other two. I’ve heard Mark Lowry many times since he embarked on his solo venture, and he has actually improved as a vocalist and performer since being on his own. And Michael English still has chops as well.
Which brings me to another point. I realize I ripped on him a little, perhaps more harshly than I should have, in a post about the “Satisfied” clip from the GVB Reunion video. I said that I was very disappointed in English’s performance in that clip. However, I have seen some clips of recent concerts of his on various websites and I must say that he really hasn’t lost all that much vocally. He sounds much better in those than he did in the Reunion clip.
Sure, he lost a little in his upper range, but his emotion and pathos makes up for that and then some. I imagine that once the new GVB group gets rolling and he performs more in that setting, one will be hard-pressed to tell that he even lost anything.
Well, enough from me. I hope to catch the group when the Homecoming tour comes to Charlottesville in a few months